“But there remains also the truth that every end in history necessarily contains a new beginning”
—Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism
Stupid Yalta
Three months before the official Nazi surrender, in February 1945, Franklin Roosevelt, Joseph Stalin, and Winston Churchil split up much of the Western world. While a great deal of negotiating had already been done, and military realities provided borders, the leaders and their teams spent eight days in Soviet-occupied Crimea hammering out the details for a new world order.
Many of the agreements in the Yalta conference, of course, were subsequently broken, but nevertheless the meeting provided the initial foundations for a post-WWII world.


Over eight decades later, on Thursday in Shenzhen, China, another meeting of three world leaders has been hailed by people like genocidal Putin propagandist Aleksandr Dugin as a “New Yalta… the dawn of a renewed world order.”
Of course, the circumstances are wildly different this time.


In 1945, the Allies were on the verge of winning the worst conflict in the history of the world, having collectively defeated fascist threats in the East and the West. In 2026, by contrast, three struggling autocrats met for an hour-long photo opportunity, for no particular reason—that we know of.
Below, they greeted each other on Tuesday. Notice how Trump wanted to stand next to Putin, but Xi had other ideas about positioning.
But why? What is the real purpose of this meeting? Cui bono?
Trading Apotheoses
The word apotheosis has two basic meanings. It can be passive, as in the culmination of development—e.g. the apotheosis of authoritarianism. Or it can be active, meaning to deify someone, to graduate them from a human identity to something more god-like.
Both of these meanings are relevant here.
Stupid Yalta is the apotheosis of Vladimir Putin’s decades-long project to use kompromat, influence operations, and psychological warfare to elevate his second-rate petro-state to the same geopolitical status as the United States and China.
For some perspective, these are the nominal GDPs of each of the nations represented.
This meeting was an extraordinary gift to Putin, granting Russia the appearance of being a legitimate superpower, when it is really much more of a global pariah.
Trump’s apotheosis, on the other hand, is more of the second variety—a self-deification. He saw Stupid Yalta as the end of U.S. history and the beginning of an era of Infinite Trump. In his mind, he will control half the world—the Western Hemisphere—leaving Putin and Xi to split up the rest.
Donald Trump believes he made a “good deal”—for half the planet. All Trump has to do in return is give Putin and Xi everything they want, including Ukraine and Taiwan.
Hegseth’s Peacock
As proof of his dominion over the Western sphere of influence, Trump sent war crime enthusiast Pete Hegseth to Central and South America to plant the American flag. So far, the trip includes Venezuela—which was taken by force and turned into a puppet state for its oil—and Colombia, where Hegseth delivered a C-130 transport aircraft to a well known narco-state.
Hegseth called Venezuela a “compliant security partner” in Caracas, explicitly invoking the “Donroe Doctrine.” And while the president of Colombia had been cajoled into joining the “Shield of Americas,” and will participate in joint “counterinsurgency operations,“ Hegseth’s request for military cooperationwas rejected—right before he arrived.
Undaunted, Hegseth will extend his tour of would-be U.S. colonies to Ecuador and Honduras.
Hegseth’s South American escapade is a transparent effort to project Trump’s desired image as the dominant Western power—while Trump peacocks with two post-communist dictators in China. But the actual effect of this performance of tinpot authoritarianism will be something entirely different.
Smuggler’s Paradise
The third wheel of Stupid Yalta, President Xi Jingping of China, has never had an easier job destroying the enemy. Xi has remained stoic, happy to watch the rise of his geopolitical partner in crime, Vladimir Putin, to the status of America’s “friend.” And more importantly, to watch the destruction of American dignity on the international stage.
Trump repeatedly referred to both Putin and Xi as his “friend” and assured Xi that “As long as you and I are in charge of things, we will never have a problem.”
Of course, Trump’s trip to China has been overshadowed in many ways by the enormous smuggling operation Trump and Howard Lutnick enabled for NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang to sell advanced chips to China. Trump’s reaction to Huang’s relationship with a suspected spy, while standing on Chinese soil was: “We spy on China and they spy on us.”
This laissez-faire attitude about espionage was highlighted by Russian state media.
The harsh light of history will show that the boundaries, institutions, and norms of the post-WWII order have all been broken down by Donald Trump’s amoral, transactional alternate reality. On the biggest stage, the entire world still revolves around his personal relationships and bank accounts.
Of course, the vast majority of Americans, who want nothing to do with this authoritarian charade, are of no value in the calculus of Stupid Yalta.
Mythological End Times
The true apotheosis of Stupid Yalta is the destruction of American post-WWII mythology. The exceptionalist “good guys” image acquired in the devil’s bargain made in 1945 has been used as a kind of… trump card in international relations for approaching a century. U.S. geopolitical posturing was backed up by a victory.
But we are the saviors of democracy no longer. Right now, America is the outspoken enemy of democracy. We are not the leader of the free world; we are a wannabe dictatorship, a third-rate autocracy with a desperate, flailing criminal in the presidency.
In many ways, there is no coming back from this rupture. The sooner we collectively absorb this new reality the better. America has proven that democracy is optional to us. Our system allowed the apparatus of government to be deployed against our allies and our citizens—and to collaborate with the enemy. Why should anyone ever trust us again?
The harsh, present reality is that we are watching the immolation of America’s mythology to serve the collapse of a failing narcissist.
While we can and must recover from the demolition of American mythology, we will now have to earn our way back to “good guys” status. And this time, it won’t be so easy. When Trump is gone, the wreckage will remain. The alliances will still be shattered. The trust will still be gone. And there will be a massive power vacuum.
Stupid Yalta was historic, but not for the reasons Trump wanted. It was the apotheosis of American failure, the end of American “exceptionalism,” and the beginning of a new era of geopolitical uncertainty and chaos. Our challenge now, in this turbulent environment, is to make a case to the world based on the future instead of the past—on vision, instead of mythology.
“As our case is new, so we must think anew, and act anew. We must disenthrall ourselves, and then we shall save our country.”
—Abraham Lincoln, December 1, 1862
Please consider becoming a paid subscriber! Grateful for your support.
If you’d prefer to donate, here is my DonorBox. 💙















"And there will be a massive power vacuum." That is the thing that keeps me up at night. Too soon to see how that might turn out. It won't be good for the average person in the world, though.
Absolutely brilliant essay, Jim. Brought tears to my eyes actually. I'm frightened and excited for the future of our country, and how well we govern moving Forward. Thank You, what a read and will reStack ASAP 🙏